eCommerceNews UK - Technology news for digital commerce decision-makers
United Kingdom
Retailers warned tighter return rules can spur chargebacks

Retailers warned tighter return rules can spur chargebacks

Wed, 18th Nov 2026 (Today)
Karen Joy Bacudo
KAREN JOY BACUDO Finance Editor

Chargebacks911 has warned retailers that tougher return policies can shift losses from refunds to chargebacks, an issue becoming more visible as merchants prepare for Black Friday.

Industry data cited by the payments disputes group points to the scale of the problem in the US returns market. Appriss Retail estimated that USD $100 billion of the USD $706 billion in merchandise returned last year was preventable fraud and abuse, equal to 14.2% of total returns.

That total included USD $14 billion in outright fraud and USD $86 billion in policy abuse, including practices such as wardrobing and bracketing. These behaviours exploit return windows and retail policies without necessarily breaking the law.

Many merchants have responded by making returns harder through fees, shorter windows and stricter proof-of-purchase rules. Yet the figures suggest those steps do not always reduce abuse.

The NRF and Happy Returns 2025 Retail Returns Landscape Report found that nearly two-thirds of consumers admitted to at least one costly returns behaviour. Separate research reported by eMarketer found that 44% of merchants that introduced return fees saw fraud increase, while 42% saw it fall.

Retailers also face a sales risk if tighter policies put off legitimate customers. Appriss Retail found that eight in 10 shoppers said a positive returns experience made them more likely to buy from a retailer again.

Chargebacks911 argued that the effects of stricter rules can also surface later in the disputes process rather than at the returns desk. Its 2026 Chargeback Field Report found that 27.1% of merchant returns involve some form of abuse, while 62% of merchants described refund abuse as a moderate or significant concern.

The same report found that 61.8% of merchants said chargebacks had increased over the past three years. It added that friendly fraud was growing faster than overall chargeback volumes.

Three-way pressure

Chargebacks911 said merchants are caught between three pressures at once: return fraud, customer dissatisfaction and chargebacks. A policy aimed at reducing one cost can raise another.

Monica Eaton, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Chargebacks911, said the dilemma becomes harder to ignore during peak shopping periods.

"Here is the trap retailers keep falling into," Eaton said. "They make returns easier and abuse goes up. They make returns harder and customers walk away. And some of that dissatisfaction can resurface as a chargeback instead. That is not necessarily a better outcome, as it can be a more expensive problem dressed up as a solution."

Merchants often handle returns abuse and chargebacks as separate operational issues, even when the same customers or patterns of behaviour may appear in both systems, Chargebacks911 said. That can make it harder to identify repeat misuse or spot where earlier intervention might have prevented a later dispute.

"We talk to merchants every day who are absorbing losses from both sides," Eaton said. "Returns abuse on one side, chargebacks on the other. Treating them as completely separate problems makes it much harder to see the patterns connecting them. If you only look at one side of the customer journey, you are only seeing half the problem."

Data gap

The warning comes as retailers head into one of the busiest periods of the year for transactions, returns and disputes. For many businesses, the challenge is not simply setting the right policy, but joining up data from different parts of the business.

Chargebacks911 said retailers that manage the period best are not necessarily those with the strictest rules, but those that can compare returns activity with later disputes and identify recurring behaviour. That includes looking at which customers appear in both processes and where a failed return may later become a chargeback claim.

Eaton said merchants should focus on distinguishing between ordinary customer behaviour and patterns that consistently generate losses.

"Peak season is not the time to discover that your returns data and your dispute data live in different systems and nobody is looking at both," Eaton said. "The question retailers should be asking right now is not, 'How do I stop returns?' but, 'How do I tell the difference between a genuine customer and a pattern of behaviour that is costing me money?' That distinction is where the problem actually gets solved."